Justice & Peace Commission
A Profile of Thomas Berry by Matthew Fox 

Evening Thoughts by Thomas Berry

Revival of the Cosmos in Theology by Elizabeth Johnson, CSJ

Retrieval of the Cosmos in Theology
by Elizabeth Johnson, CSJ
As the 21st century rapidly approaches, there is a vital theme largely absent from the thinking of most North American theologians, namely, the whole world as God's good creation. There are a few notable exceptions, but surveying our work as a whole would quickly make this absence clear.

This mainstream neglect of "the cosmos" by recent decades of mainstream Catholic theology has two deleterious results. It enfeebles theology in its basic task of interpreting the whole of reality in the light of faith, thus compromising the intellectual integrity of theology. And it blocks what should be theology's powerful contribution to the religious practice of justice and mercy for the threatened Earth, thereby endangering the moral integrity of theology.

Theology is potentially the most comprehensive of fields. If there is only one God, and if this God is the Creator of all that exists, then everything is encompassed in the scope of theology's interest. Traditionally this is expressed in the idea that theology deals with three major areas: God, humanity, and world. Nor can these elements be separated, for, as the history of theology makes evident, every understanding of God corresponds to a particular understanding of the natural and the human.

Early Christian and medieval theologians took this view for granted, interpreting the natural world as God's good creation, a revealing pathway to the knowledge of God, and a partner in salvation. It was common for them to say that God has put two books at our disposal, the book of sacred scripture and the book of nature: If we learn how to read the book of nature right, we will hear God's word and be led to knowledge about God's wisdom, power, and love.

Medieval theology brought God, humanity, and the world into an ordered harmony. The resulting synthesis not only shaped art, architecture, liturgy, and poetry; it also remained for centuries a guiding influence in Catholic theology even when its underlying world picture was discredited by scientific advance.

And scientific advance there was, as the names of Copernicus, Galileo, Newton, and later Darwin, Einstein, Heisenberg, and many others imply. Strange as it may seem in the light of a fifteen hundred year old heritage, after the Reformation neither Catholic nor Protestant theology kept pace the new scientific worldviews. Instead, they focused on God and the self, leaving the world to the side..

Today one could go through a whole course of study in college, seminary, or university and never encounter the subject (of cosmology). And yet nature is one of the three main pillars of theology, along with God and humanity. What is needed now, I am convinced, is a fully inclusive turn to the heavens and the earth, a return to cosmology, in order to restore fullness of vision and get theology back on the track from which it diverged a few hundred years ago.

Since theology is the study of God and all things in the light of God, shrinking attention to humanity apart from the rest of creation simply does not do justice to theology's intrinsic mission. Even more, ignoring the cosmos has a deleterious effect insofar as it paves the way for theology to retreat to other-worldliness, disparage matter, body, and the Earth, and offer interpretations of reality far removed from the way things actually work. We must engage the world.

When theology today opens its door to the natural world, it is met with a wondrous array of insights. Medieval cosmology, which saw the world as geocentric, static and unchanging, hierarchically ordered and centered on humanity, is gone. But gone too is the Enlightenment prejudice that held a mechanistic and deterministic view of nature inimitable in many ways to religious values. Instead, contemporary science is discovering a natural world that is surprisingly dynamic, organic, self-organizing, indeterminate, chancy, boundless, and open to the mystery of reality. Enormous discoveries are being made in our day.

  • The world is almost unimaginably old. About 15 billion years ago a single numinous speck exploded in an outpouring of matter and energy, shaping a universe that is still expanding. Five billion years ago an aging, first generation star exploded, spewing out elements that coalesced to form our sun and its planets, including Earth. The human is only recently arrived.
  • The world is almost incomprehensibly large. Over one hundred billion galaxies, each comprised of one hundred billion stars, and no one knows how many moons and planets, all of this visible and audible matter being only a fraction of the matter in the universe. We humans inhabit a small planet orbiting a medium-sized star toward the edge of one spiral galaxy.
  • The world is almost mind-numbingly dynamic. Out of the Big Bang, the stars; out of the stardust, the Earth; out of the Earth, single-celled living creatures; out of evolutionary life and death of these creatures, human beings with a consciousness and freedom that concentrates the self-transcendence of matter itself. Human beings are the universe become conscious of itself. We are the cantors of the universe.
  • The world is almost unfathomably organic. Everything is connected with everything else; nothing conceivable is isolated. We are also biologically interconnected. Human genetic structure closely parallels the DNA of other creatures - bacteria, grasses, bluebirds, horses, the great gray whales. We have all evolved from common ancestors and are kin in the shared history of life.

These and other discoveries of contemporary science coalesce into a picture of the world calling for new interpretations, especially as classical dualisms can no longer be maintained.

Besides an intellectual reason for theology's turn to the heavens and the earth, there is a compelling moral reason as well. In our day the human race is inflicting devastation on the life-systems and other living species of our home planet, havoc which has reached crisis proportions and even, in some places ecological collapse. Due to the increasing demands of consumerist economies on the one hand and burgeoning population on the other, we are exploiting Earth's resources without regard for long-term sustainability. In light of the devastation, the turn to the heavens and the earth bears the mark of genuine conversion of mind and heart, with repentance for the lack of love and the violence visited on the living planet. As we turn, we will be looking for thought patterns that will transform our species- centeredness and enable us to grant not just instrumental worth but intrinsic value to the natural world.

Moral reflection about the natural world under threat becomes complex when we take into consideration the organic links that exist between exploitation of the Earth and injustice among human beings themselves. The voices of the poor and of women bring to light the fact that structures of social domination are chief among the ways that abuse of the Earth is accomplished.

I am not suggesting that we just think through a new theology of creation, but that cosmology be a framework within which all theological topics be rethought. There is hard work ahead. We need to appreciate all over again that the whole universe is a sacrament, vivified by the presence of the Creator Spirit. We need to realize that its destruction is tantamount to sacrilege. And we need to fathom that human beings are part of the mystery and magnificence of this universe, not lords of the manor but partners with God in helping creation to grow and prosper.

Elizabeth Johnson, CSJ, is a widely respected feminist theologian and faculty member in the Theology Department at Fordham University. Her books include Women, Earth, & Creator Spirit (Paulist Press, 1993) and She Who Is: The Mystery of God in Feminist Theological Discourse (Crossroad, 1992).